skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

expensive hotel. small pool. the bar is at least decent ... read more
Agnes Szprycha via google.com - Aug 1, 2018
Not the place to go if you want luxury in fire island...but absolutely the best place if you want a good time. Drag queens are every where and it is a good place to pre game before you go to Cherry's bar.
Stephanie Garcia via google.com - Aug 1, 2018
The only thing open this season ...
The only thing open this season is the adjacent Ice Palace bar and nightclub. The actual hotel burned pretty much to the ground in Spring 2015. So, the summer season of 2015 is out of the question for lodging... The pool is open. Best events at the Ice Palace nightclub are those hosted by promoter Daniel Nardicio. Though numerous per ... read more
Todd H. via yelp.com - Jun 13, 2015
This is a GREAT place.  While much ...
This is a GREAT place.  While much of Fire Island can be insanely pretentious and expensive (can you say FIRE ISLAND PINES?!?!?), the Grove Hotel (which is its real name) and the Ice Palace (which is the dance floor adjacent to the bar) is a cost-effective, convenient, clean, and fun place to stay.  This is not luxury - and if you wa ... read more
Thomas S. via yelp.com - Sep 29, 2012
The only reason I gave this place ...
The only reason I gave this place a four star rating is because it was in Fire Island....who stays in the room in fire island?!?  Anywhere else, this place would get a one star review.The rooms are tiny, but do have all the accommodations you need for a trip to fire island.  Lets break it down, there is a bed for sleeping or other na ... read more
K K. via yelp.com - Sep 18, 2011
I'm hoping this is the right place ...
I'm hoping this is the right place to review the location is not accurate and the name is slightly off. Also, am I the first person to review since the aughts?  Is this a case of What happens on Fire Island stays on Fire Island? Well, its called the Grove Hotel now and the Ice Palace is still going strong. First well discuss the acco ... read more
Jay B. via yelp.com - Jun 19, 2011
After arriving at the Pines walking ...
After arriving at the Pines walking, err stopping in the meat rack, and then recouping in Cherry Grove, it was nice to get advice from a lesbian bar-b-quing hot dogs that we had to see Porsche while on the island.At the Ice Palace there was a small group of gays anticipating the arrival of a lovely drag queen who claimed to be drunk ... read more
Anthony S. via yelp.com - Aug 1, 2009
Oldest gay resort
A true new England Beach Resort.Outstanding Headline entertainment from Lady GaGa, Porsche, Shequida( From Americas Got Talent) D.J. Susan Morabito,Peter Rauhofer, Junior Vasquez and many more. The club and hotel/pool attracts Boys to Men w/ a variety of events from mellow afternoons w/ Drag Bingo and Broadway at the beach w/ broadwa ... read more
Jedronk via yellowpages.com - Mar 13, 2009
Oldest gay resort – A true new England B...
Oldest gay resort – A true new England Beach Resort.Outstanding Headline entertainment from Lady GaGa, Porsche, Shequida( From Americas Got Talent) D.J. Susan Morabito,Peter Rauhofer, Junior Vasquez and many more. The club and hotel/pool attracts Boys to Men w/ a variety of events from mellow afternoons w/ Drag Bingo and Broadway at ... read more
Jedronk via citysearch.com - Mar 13, 2009
I've never had a chance to visit ...
I've never had a chance to visit the Ice Palace on a weeknight.  But when I manage to visit Cherry Grove on summer weekends it is a stop on my itinerary!
Alphonse G. via yelp.com - Mar 12, 2009
The Ice Palace, an old, wooden ...
The Ice Palace, an old, wooden dance hall and bar, is the center of the Cherry Grove universe! Mix one part queer Dirty Dancing's Kellerman's club house, one part Olivia cruise, and two parts drinks, drunks, dykes, and drag queens. Trivia on Tuesdays with Sal. "Broadway at the Beach" open mike night on Mondays. Ariel Sinclair comedy ... read more
Billy A. via yelp.com - Jul 18, 2007
A favorite Cherry Grove nightspot that o...
A favorite Cherry Grove nightspot that offers hot parties, cool cocktails and fabulous people-watching. – The SceneThe Ice Palace sits next to the Grove Hotel and from the outside deck and bar, guests can look out over the bay or watch hotel patrons at the large outdoor swimming pool. In the evenings the Ice Palace caters to a varied ... read more
Contributor via citysearch.com - Jul 26, 2006
Great Music - Cutrell and Feldmen
It was great to hear the lively music of Brandon Cutrell and Ray Feldmen on July 27. Bring them back more often. Karen and Michael are always great, love thier style and talent.
lthouse via yellowpages.com - Jul 31, 2005
Great Music - Cutrell and Feldmen – It w...
Great Music - Cutrell and Feldmen – It was great to hear the lively music of Brandon Cutrell and Ray Feldmen on July 27. Bring them back more often. Karen and Michael are always great, love thier style and talent.
lthouse via citysearch.com - Jul 31, 2005
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
Google+FoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor